Member-only story
The Legend of Cropsey: Staten Island’s Most Haunting Urban Myth
A Local Legend Turned National Nightmare
In the dense thicket of trees, amid the abandoned ruins of buildings left to rot, Staten Island harbors one of America’s most chilling urban legends. It’s the story of Cropsey, a name whispered by generations of children and feared by parents throughout New York. What began as a local legend about a boogeyman roaming the woods evolved into a terrifying reality in the late 20th century when a series of child disappearances took place, leaving the community shaken and fearful.
Cropsey was more than just a myth — for many, he was Staten Island’s own nightmare, a ghost that haunted the woods, a malevolent spirit lurking in the shadows, waiting to prey on the innocent. The line between fiction and reality blurred as the legend grew. And what was once a story designed to scare children around campfires became a story that terrified an entire city.
But how did this legend start? And why did it strike so much fear into the hearts of those who called Staten Island home?
This is the story of Cropsey.
The Origins of the Cropsey Legend: From Campfire Tales to Local Lore
Like many urban legends, Cropsey’s story has no single definitive version. Instead, the tale of Cropsey has been passed down through generations, morphing into various forms depending on who was telling it and when. At its core, the story always revolved around a deranged man who lived in the woods of Staten Island, emerging from the shadows to kidnap children who wandered too far from home.
The Campfire Boogeyman
In its earliest form, the Cropsey legend was nothing more than a campfire tale. Parents and older children would tell stories of a madman, often described as an escaped mental patient, who lived in the ruins of an abandoned hospital or the dense forests of Staten Island. The man was said to prey on children, abducting them and spiriting them away to some hidden location, never to be seen again. His name, “Cropsey,” was often whispered in hushed tones, as if saying it too loudly might summon him.
